Gabby Barrett has received several nominations and wins at the CMT Music Awards, American Music Awards, Country Music Association Awards, Academy of Country Music Awards, and more.
| YEAR | RESULT | AWARD | CATEGORY |
| 2023 | N/A | 2023 CMT Music Awards | Video of the Year for: “Pick Me Up” |
| 2023 | N/A | 2023 CMT Music Awards | Female Video of the Year for: “Pick Me Up” |
| 2022 | Nominated | 2022 Country Now Awards | Favorite Female Artist |
| 2022 | Nominated | 2022 Country Now Awards | Favorite Love Song for: “Pick Me Up” |
| 2022 | Nominated | 2022 CMT Music Awards | Female Video of the Year for: “Footprints on the Moon” |
| 2022 | Nominated | 2022 iHeartRadio Music Awards | Country Song of the Year for: “The Good Ones” |
| 2022 | Nominated | 57th Academy Of Country Music Awards | Female Artist of the Year |
| 2022 | Won | 2022 Billboard Women in Music Awards | Rising Star Award presented by Honda |
| 2021 | Nominated | 2021 Country Now Awards | Favorite Female Artist |
| 2021 | Won | 2021 Country Now Awards | Favorite Female Empowerment Anthem for: “Footprints on the Moon” |
| 2021 | Nominated | 2021 Country Now Awards | Favorite Sentimental Song for: “The Good Ones” |
| 2021 | Won | 49th Annual American Music Awards | Favorite Country Album for: Goldmine |
| 2021 | Won | 49th Annual American Music Awards | Favorite Country Song for: “The Good Ones” |
| 2021 | Nominated | 49th Annual American Music Awards | Favorite Female Country Artist |
| 2021 | Nominated | 55th Annual CMA Awards | New Artist Of The Year |
| 2021 | Nominated | 55th Annual CMA Awards | Female Vocalist Of The Year |
| 2021 | Nominated | 55th Annual CMA Awards | Single Of The Year for: “The Good Ones” |
| 2021 | Nominated | 55th Annual CMA Awards | Song Of The Year for: “The Good Ones” |
| 2021 | Won | 2021 CMT Artists Of The Year | Artist Of The Year |
| 2021 | Nominated | 2021 iHeartRadio Music Awards | Best Lyrics for: “I Hope” (ft. Charlie Puth) |
| 2021 | Nominated | 2021 iHeartRadio Music Awards | Best Collaboration for: “I Hope” (ft. Charlie Puth) |
| 2021 | Nominated | 2021 iHeartRadio Music Awards | Country Song Of The Year for: “I Hope” |
| 2021 | Won | 2021 iHeartRadio Music Awards | Best New Country Artist |
| 2021 | Nominated | 56th Academy Of Country Music Awards | Single Of The Year for: “I Hope” |
| 2021 | Won | 56th Academy Of Country Music Awards | New Female Artist Of The Year |
| 2021 | Nominated | 2021 Billboard Music Awards | Top Hot 100 Song for: “I Hope” (ft. Charlie Puth) |
| 2021 | Nominated | 2021 Billboard Music Awards | Top Radio Song for: “I Hope” (ft. Charlie Puth) |
| 2021 | Nominated | 2021 Billboard Music Awards | Top Selling Song for: “I Hope” (ft. Charlie Puth) |
| 2021 | Nominated | 2021 Billboard Music Awards | Top Country Album for: Goldmine |
| 2021 | Nominated | 2021 Billboard Music Awards | Top Country Artist |
| 2021 | Nominated | 2021 Billboard Music Awards | Top New Artist |
| 2021 | Won | 2021 Billboard Music Awards | Top Collaboration for: “I Hope” (ft. Charlie Puth) |
| 2021 | Won | 2021 Billboard Music Awards | Top Country Song for: “I Hope” |
| 2021 | Won | 2021 Billboard Music Awards | Top Country Female Artist |
| 2021 | Won | RIAA’s Gold & Platinum Class of 2020 | RIAA First Timer Gold Record for: “The Good Ones” |
| 2021 | Won | RIAA’s Gold & Platinum Class of 2020 | RIAA First Timer Triple Platinum Record for: “I Hope” |
| 2020 | Won | 2020 iHeartRadio Titanium Awards | One Billion Total Audience Spins for: “I Hope” (ft. Charlie Puth) |
| 2020 | Nominated | 48th Annual American Music Awards | Favorite Female Artist – Country |
| 2020 | Nominated | 54th Annual Country Music Association Awards | Single of the Year for: “I Hope” |
| 2020 | Nominated | 54th Annual Country Music Association Awards | New Artist of the Year |
| 2020 | Won | 2020 CMT Music Awards | Breakthrough Video of the Year for: “I Hope” |
| 2020 | Nominated | 55th Academy of Country Music Awards | New Female Vocalist of the Year |
| 2014 | Won | 2014 First Night Sing-Off | Judges Winner |
| 2014 | Won | 2014 Kean Quest Talent Search | Judges Choice Winner |